Logo, Otto's Custom Jewelry - Jewelry Store

(941) 388-4236  
413 St. Armands Circle   
Sarasota, FL 34236   

Local Jewelry Store

Necklace - Jewelry Store


Let our master jeweler create custom jewelry that's perfect for you. Our store also offers gold, platinum, and silver coating services to give old pieces a fresh, new look.

Repairing Jewelry - Jewelry Store


Restore your broken bauble or damaged timepiece to its original condition with prompt, on-site jewelry and watch repairs at Otto's Custom Jewelry. Our professionals repair your piece quickly.

Necklace - Jewelry Store


Check out all the unique and stunning jewelry options we have to offer you when you view our gallery. From rings and bracelets to pendants and necklaces, you'll love our beautiful collection.
* Catering to Your Needs for More Than 40 Years *

Who We Are

A Beautiful and award winning jewelry store located in the heart of Sarasota, Florida, Otto's Custom Jewelry is here to serve your most unique desires. To this day master jeweler and the founder's son, Misha Rezac maintains the family tradition of quality.

Designing from the age of 10, he has more than 30 years of experience in his trade. After his father, Otto, passed in 1981, Misha took over the family business at the age of 20. Today, we're a full-service jewelry store offering exquisite designs, beautiful baubles, and a one-of-a-kind experience.

Contact our jewelry store and let us cater to your unique needs.
Find out More About Us